The Pattern

I can't do anything halfway. Once I start cleaning, I don't want to stop until the whole house is done. Once I start eating healthy, I want to cut out sugar completely. Once I commit to working out, I want to do it every single day. There's no small version of anything for me, which is exactly why I put all of it off for so long. I feel like once I start, I won’t be able to have good things anymore or relax for a few days, so it's hard to give that up.

Where It Actually Comes From

Someone online described this pattern as conditional love, warmth that only shows up when you do something well. My immediate thought was, “I didn’t get warmth at all. If I did something well, it was just expected, like good grades or good behavior.” My family isn't big on compliments, expressing deep emotions, or hugs that mean something. I was the weird one, deeply emotional and liking those kinds of things. Only now do I think I wasn’t the weird one. They definitely had some issues.

The other half of it was criticism. When I did try to help, it was rarely good enough. I'd be criticized for not offering soon enough, or for not doing a good enough job, or judged for not knowing how to do something nobody had ever taught me. I still don't know how to change a vacuum cleaner bag. When my first apartment flooded, I had to call home at two in the morning because I didn't know what to do. School taught me trigonometry. I’ve never once needed to know the tangent of anything, but no one ever taught me anything practical. Not knowing was embarrassing, and the embarrassment stuck. Even when I wasn't doing anything, that look lingered, the one that asks why you aren't doing more.

The expectations weren't always consistent, either. I was told to pitch in and help clean whenever we visited someone's house, but when guests came to ours, they were expected to work. In college, my best friend flew out to spend a week with me, and we spent a weekend at my parents' place. My mom complained to me that my friend was reading instead of helping her fold the laundry. Okay, first of all, that’s just weird. You want her folding your underwear??? Really??? No, she was my guest. She had no obligation to fold anyone's clothes. If anything, we should be trying to make her feel more comfortable. That’s an unrealistic expectation, and a little creepy.

I'm beginning to wonder whether that's part of why I approach things the way I do now. Starting something meant opening myself up to criticism, and once I started, finishing everything felt like the safest way to avoid hearing that I hadn't done enough. When I hit something I can't figure out now, like a part of the vacuum I don't know how to fix, it pulls me straight back to that feeling. Thank goodness, now we have YouTube! There are tons of how-to videos.

If meeting the bar never got a response, going past it might be the only strategy that ever felt like it had a shot at getting one. All-or-nothing isn't only about momentum. It might also be an old bid for a reaction that ordinary effort never bought me, and a way to avoid the judgment that half-effort invited.

The One Thing That Worked

I can think of one place in my life where I successfully practiced moderation: my grandmother's molasses cookies. I could eat the whole bag if I let myself, but for a while I ate two small ones after dinner and never went past that.

Part of the reason is that I had a gallbladder problem, and eating the wrong things hurt badly enough that I had to be extremely careful. This happened after I had already baked St. Patrick’s Day desserts for work, though, and I had plenty more in the freezer. My philosophy is to bake more than you need and have variety because people like different things. I started with a single bite, then two the next day, then three the day after that, seeing how my body responded. Eventually I worked up to one shamrock-shaped cookie, then two. Two satisfied the craving enough, and I thought going past that would cost me.

That's slow and steady, done almost perfectly, and I didn't have to try to be disciplined at all. Willpower didn't make it possible. Two things did, which cleaning and working out never gave me: a clear boundary (a number, a size, a time of day, a recipe tied to someone I loved) and immediate physical feedback. When I overdid it, I knew right away. Cleaning and working out are open-ended, and the consequences show up late, if at all. That's exactly where my all-or-nothing instinct takes over.

Momentum Isn't the Problem

Momentum isn't actually the enemy. Stopping mid-task, when restarting costs that much energy, isn't irrational. For some things, riding momentum all the way through is genuinely the smarter move, not a flaw to correct.

This particular round of all-or-nothing came out of running out of patience. Spirit told me, more than once, that help was on the way, something big. I believed it and held onto it, and the waiting dragged on long enough that I finally hit a wall. I decided I wasn't going to keep hoping something would show up and fix things for me. I was going to handle it myself, the way I always do.

The real issue shows up when momentum demands more than my body or schedule can give. That's exactly what happened when I decided to get healthy all at once, no easing in. I set a timer every hour at work to do a quick round of fast walking, stretching, and holding an Asian squat to improve mobility. My body wasn't ready, and I hurt myself. I admit I was a little concerned about not giving my muscles the traditional day off between workouts, but I was told to do it this way, so I tried. I should have listened to my instincts.

The skill isn't eliminating momentum. It's knowing when to let it run and when to interrupt it on purpose, before your body makes that decision for you.

Building a Container on Purpose

The cookies worked because the container came first. I think that's part of the fix: decide the boundary before you start, not while you're already moving and it's too late to stop.

That might look like one room instead of "the house," fifteen minutes on a timer instead of "until I'm done," two workouts a week to start instead of every day. The container isn't a smaller version of the goal. It's what makes starting safe enough to actually begin.

I'm still learning this one. That push left me with a pulled muscle and barely able to walk yesterday. My calf is currently reminding me why it matters.

Giving Myself the Grace They Never Gave Me

So how do you get out of that feeling? For me, it started with the laundry story. Watching an unrealistic expectation land on someone else showed me what it looks like from the outside. You can't see it as clearly when it's aimed at you.

There were plenty of others. As the oldest, I was the built-in babysitter for my brothers while my parents went out to dinner, shows, and concerts, and if the boys cried, somehow that was my fault. They were my parents' kids, and raising them was my parents' responsibility, not mine. When my grandmother went into a care home because she couldn't walk, my grandfather was left falling and lonely in the house. I went to stay with him because I wanted to spend time with him before he passed and help where I could. When I asked what was expected of me, I was told to keep my room clean. It grew into far more than that, and eventually into more than I could handle. They really needed a nurse. I did what I could with the strength and health I had then because I loved them.

Now when that old feeling shows up, I try to laugh and say, "That's unrealistic," and I give myself the grace they never gave me. I tell myself: you're tired. If all you can do today is dust, that's an accomplishment. Tomorrow you can clean the floors, and the next day you can clean the bathroom. That's good enough. If it's all you're physically and emotionally capable of, it's enough. It doesn't mean you're lazy, and it doesn't mean you don't care. You're still worthy, and you're still lovable.

I'm learning that I don't have to exhaust myself to prove I've done enough. If I clean one room today, the rest of the house can wait. If I exercise twice this week instead of seven times, that's still progress. And if somebody thinks I should be doing more? Well, they're welcome to come over and clean my bathroom.” 😂

If this writing resonates with you, the newsletter is free, but there’s also a support link below for anyone who wants to help support the work.